“We’re going on very minimal information”: WHO officials complained in internal meetings about China’s lack of data-sharing at the beginning of the coronavirus outbreak, even as it praised Beijing repeatedly in public, the AP has found.
“Since the beginning of the outbreak, we have been continuously sharing information on the epidemic with the WHO and the international community in an open, transparent and responsible manner,” said Liu Mingzhu, an official with the National Health Commission’s International Department, at aThe race to find the genetic map of the virus started in late December, according to the story that unfolds in interviews, documents and the WHO recordings.
Chinese law states that research institutes cannot conduct experiments on potentially dangerous new viruses without approval from top health authorities. Although the law is intended to keep experiments safe, it gives top health officials wide-ranging powers over what lower-level labs can or cannot do.
On Jan. 5, the Shanghai Public Clinical Health Center, led by famed virologist Zhang Yongzhen, was the latest to sequence the virus. He submitted it to the GenBank database, where it sat awaiting review, and notified the National Health Commission. He warned them that the new virus was similar to SARS and likely infectious.
A major factor behind the gag order, some say, was that Chinese CDC researchers wanted to publish their papers first. “They wanted to take all the credit,” said Li Yize, a coronavirus researcher at the University of Pennsylvania. The article also embarrassed WHO officials. Dr. Tom Grein, chief of WHO’s acute events management team, said the agency looked “doubly, incredibly stupid.” Van Kerkhove, the American expert, acknowledged WHO was “already late” in announcing the new virus and told colleagues that it was critical to push China.
“We have to be consistent,” Ryan said. “The danger now is that despite our good intent...especially if something does happen, there will be a lot of finger-pointing at WHO.” Supaporn compared her sequence with Zhang’s and found it was a 100% match, confirming that the Thai patient was ill with the same virus detected in Wuhan. Another Thai lab got the same results. That day, Thailand informed the WHO, said Tanarak Plipat, deputy director-general of the Department of Disease Control at Thailand’s Ministry of Public Health.
“The pressure is intense in an outbreak to make sure you’re right,” said Peter Daszak, president of the EcoHealthAlliance in New York. “It’s actually worse to go out to go to the public with a story that’s wrong because the public completely lose confidence in the public health response.”Infectious diseases expert John Mackenzie, who served on a WHO emergency committee during the outbreak, praised the speed of Chinese researchers in sequencing the virus.
WHO went back and forth. Van Kerkhove said in a press briefing that “it is certainly possible there is limited human-to-human transmission.” But hours later, WHO seemed to backtrack, andthat “preliminary investigations conducted by the Chinese authorities have found no clear evidence of human-to-human transmission” – a statement that later became fodder for critics.
Deutschland Neuesten Nachrichten, Deutschland Schlagzeilen
Similar News:Sie können auch ähnliche Nachrichten wie diese lesen, die wir aus anderen Nachrichtenquellen gesammelt haben.
China delayed releasing coronavirus info, frustrating WHO'Impressive ... beyond words': That’s how WHO described China’s transparency at the beginning of the coronavirus outbreak. But in private, WHO officials complained as China sat on releasing the genome for over a week after 3 government labs obtained it.
Weiterlesen »
In nod to #MeToo, China codifies sexual harassment by lawTwo years ago, Zhou Xiaoxuan publicly accused one of China's most recognizable people of groping and forcibly kissing her, setting off a firestorm in a country that did not specify sexual harassment as a legal offence.
Weiterlesen »
China delayed releasing coronavirus info, frustrating WHOIn January, the WHO praised China for what they called a quick and transparent response to the coronavirus. But behind the scenes, it was a different story: one of significant delays by China and considerable frustration by WHO officials, AP has found.
Weiterlesen »
Trump is making America more like ChinaWe must not allow the nation's dominant political party to use a distorted fun-house argument about free speech to twist the law to the point that the President's word cannot be challenged. Unless we really do want to give him a shot at president for life, just like his counterpart in Beijing, writes Rebecca MacKinnon
Weiterlesen »
China buys U.S. soybeans after halt to U.S. purchases ordered: sourcesState-owned Chinese firms bought at least three cargoes of U.S. soybeans on Monday, even as sources in China said the government had told them to halt purchases after Washington said it would eliminate special treatment for Hong Kong to punish Beijing.
Weiterlesen »
Trump's protest response gives China a propaganda win on Hong KongPresident Trump calling protesters “thugs” was a response that might have appeared on the pages of China's own government-controlled newspapers about Hong Kong | Analysis by jgriffiths
Weiterlesen »