Caroline Mala Corbin: How the 303 Creative web designer's case could allow for anti-LGBTQ discrimination. - NBCNewsTHINK
For this reason, the proposed website statement, the second issue, might not be “speech” at all. It depends on the ruling on the first issue. If it turns out that 303 Creative does not have a free speech right to refuse service to same-sex couples, publishing a statement on its website that it will not provide wedding services to gay and lesbian couples could be characterized as discriminatory conduct that triggers no free speech review.
The challenge here is how to classify 303 Creative’s making or refusing to make a website for same-sex couples. Is that pure speech? If so, Colorado’s public accommodations law is unconstitutional unless the government can show that the law is necessary to accomplish a government goal of the utmost importance. Is it pure conduct? If so, it does not trigger, never mind violate, the free speech clause.
Colorado’s law actually bars companies that open their doors to the public from refusing to serve people based on certain characteristics like sexual orientation. That’s a regulation of conduct. If the place of public accommodation is a website designer, it might incidentally affect speech, but the law itself is not targeting speech. Consequently, its odds of being constitutional are much higher than if it were pure speech.
Deutschland Neuesten Nachrichten, Deutschland Schlagzeilen
Similar News:Sie können auch ähnliche Nachrichten wie diese lesen, die wir aus anderen Nachrichtenquellen gesammelt haben.
Supreme Court again confronts case pitting free speech against LGBTQ rightsThe court is hearing oral arguments in the case from Lorie Smith five years after hearing the case brought by Jack Phillips, a Colorado baker who refused to bake a cake for a same-sex wedding.
Weiterlesen »
Supreme Court To Hear Case on Whether Website Designer Can Refuse Service to LGBTQ Customers“Colorado is censoring and compelling my speech and really forcing me to pour my creativity into creating messages that violate my convictions,” the web designer said.
Weiterlesen »
Supreme Court hears clash between LGBTQ and business owners' rightsThe case involves a Colorado web designer who says state law prevents her from designing wedding website because she believes that marriage should only be between a man and a woman.
Weiterlesen »
LGBTQ Protections at Center of Supreme Court Case Pitting Free Speech Against Gay MarriageThe case comes at a time when the court is dominated 6-3 by conservatives and following a series of cases in which the justices have sided with religious plaintiffs.
Weiterlesen »
Supreme Court hears case pitting free speech against LGBTQ rightsWhen the Supreme Court convenes for oral arguments Monday, it will be confronted with an issue it has been asked to resolve before in court fights involving bakers, a florist, and now, a web designer.
Weiterlesen »
Supreme Court hears case that could undercut LGBTQ rightsThe Supreme Court will hear arguments today in a case that could undercut LGBTQ rights. The high court will consider whether a Colorado-based web designer is obligated under her state’s laws to design websites for weddings of same-sex couples.
Weiterlesen »